|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 11:27:52 GMT -8
Post by witch1 on Jul 23, 2008 11:27:52 GMT -8
S the Night falls unheralded. Maybe we'll have a torchlight lynching?
The true alignment of BS PI will hopefully rock a few boats, which should settle down at the end of the Night.
I'd like some input from my dead covenmates over the question of claiming. I half suspect that I might have given myself away by voting at all when I did; without protection I'm dead meat should someone try and eat me, and if I die the investigation results are lost. Admittedly only one counts now.
Comments? Toughts?
Should I claim right now, before Pleo posts up BS PI's faction?
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 11:45:01 GMT -8
Post by Pleonast on Jul 23, 2008 11:45:01 GMT -8
Obviously, you have no more powers. But enjoy plotting.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 11:55:33 GMT -8
Post by witch1 on Jul 23, 2008 11:55:33 GMT -8
Ok, I decided against the immediate claim. But I am worried about being a target Tonight. I'd like your thoughts.
Right now, I'm leaning towards a claim where I hit "submit" at 7:59pm for Dawn at 8:00pm. I'll back it by ID'ing Roosh.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 12:03:11 GMT -8
Post by witch1 on Jul 23, 2008 12:03:11 GMT -8
I think the player to be looked at now is CIAS. Can we all spend some time on him? Any major inconsistencies?
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 13:05:22 GMT -8
Post by witch3 on Jul 23, 2008 13:05:22 GMT -8
I think you should claim right before Dawn and tell that Roosh was a witch to confirm yourself. No need to let them know there is another of us dead. Let them think we still have a power. You would be a sitting duck then so play it as you see fit. You could wait to claim until my role is about to be revealed, then confirm yourself. Whichever you think is best.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 13:08:26 GMT -8
Post by witch3 on Jul 23, 2008 13:08:26 GMT -8
I think CIAS is kosher. Diggit voted for Nanook I think because he knew that Nookie was lying about Boozy. All of the wolves knew. Take a look at anyone who dropped any hints that Nookie was lying after he revealed Boozy to be a wolf instead of undead.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 13:34:22 GMT -8
Post by witch3 on Jul 23, 2008 13:34:22 GMT -8
If you claim now, you can re-confirm story as town and out Hal as a wolf as well. If Nanook dies overnight (hopefully), they will need someone to lynch tomorrow.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 13:56:30 GMT -8
Post by witch3 on Jul 23, 2008 13:56:30 GMT -8
Interestinger and interestinger. Nanook get modkilled for editing. :headsmack: I say go ahead and claim before dawn with the Roosh reveal, and a Sheep in Wolf's clothing for the lynch.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 23:54:06 GMT -8
Post by witch2 on Jul 23, 2008 23:54:06 GMT -8
I say POST right BEFORE Dawn, and say two Things: Roosh = Witch. Hal = Wolf.
That's The gist of what needs to be said before you Die. YOU MUST get those two pieces of Data out before this Night Ends.
Because IF Nanook is not lying, then we witches are safe, and we've done a d**n fine job (taking out a wolf, a Vamp, and a Cabal with our skills (even if the Cabal "helped").
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 23:57:21 GMT -8
Post by witch2 on Jul 23, 2008 23:57:21 GMT -8
And that's really interesting though- Cabal can block, never figured they'd block the Vamp and try to use that to their abilities. Niiice.
(though it DOES mean then when I died, the OTHER Vamp had to kill me?) -That means there had to be 2 Vamps. One targetting Me (that means the Vampire is NOT a newbie player, and probably knows something about it (ie: it's not their first game of mafia/they READ the offboard sites).
Because that was a random NK on me outta no where if Nanook WAS NOT involved in it. It also means though the WOLVES were BLOCKED that night. If that's the case then they attacked Hockey (Which could give credence to the CIAS reading that Dotchan was vamped (as the wolves might have tried a 2nd time to take you out Hockey)....
But it's all things that bear looking at at Dawn.
The key right now is: The Town NEEDS to know Hal is a Wolf as LATE as possible. (as the Vig thing is really low)
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 23:59:06 GMT -8
Post by witch2 on Jul 23, 2008 23:59:06 GMT -8
Also:
*doh, forgot- Diggit killed me. So scratch that whole issue. That means though:WHO KILLED HOCKEY? As the WOLVES probably picked Me as the target. So where was the 3rd Kill? Did a Vamp Target Hockey Night 2, and then the Wolves Targeted Hockey Night 3? That's VERY ODD and suspicious to me... I'm wary of CIAS now.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 23, 2008 23:59:57 GMT -8
Post by witch2 on Jul 23, 2008 23:59:57 GMT -8
And still paranoid about Storyteller- he COULD be the Omega. If that's the case, then just keep lynching Wolves and if it gets to the endgame and there's a free lynch- lynch Story willingly (an idea to suggest in Day 4 or whatnot)
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 24, 2008 0:04:09 GMT -8
Post by witch2 on Jul 24, 2008 0:04:09 GMT -8
And final thoughts:
To those complaining about the game being "too easy"/"lynches set out". Consider it this way: Would you rather play in a mafia game where it's 16 town vs. 4 wolves, or 16 towns vs. 1 wolf? -Yeah, the wolf gets more time to hide and all, but jesus- that just means "the game" starts out later, but it FAVORS town whenever it officially "starts" with the numbers game. A scum being lynched is ALWAYS a good thing in games like this.
-Worry about the Necro when it starts to become a problem. You kill off Hal, and the wolves will become PFK. They will become an SK that HAS to try to kill the Necro if they want a shot at the Win. That's what you have GOT to do. Lynch them down and grind down the opposition. Right now there's a chance of there being 3 named Wolves out there (Hal, Pedes, and Diggit), if that's the case, one of those COULD be the Alpha wolf/omega wolf or whatnot. If so, then Storyteller can be confirmed at least. And the Freemasons should consider then sharing results if they've FOUND other freemasons- especially if there's only a Vamp/Necro combo out there and maybe 2 Wolves (if the Cabal TRULY is finished).
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 24, 2008 7:48:09 GMT -8
Post by witch1 on Jul 24, 2008 7:48:09 GMT -8
There's some interesting discussion in the game thread. Hawkeyeop (?) points out that so long as one of the three Witches are alive that we're safe from losing the information we've gathered.
We, there's only one of me. So I think I'd better claim just before Dawn. I'll draft a post and have it ready to send soon, but won't submit it until shortly before 8pm tomorrow evening.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 24, 2008 8:41:48 GMT -8
Post by witch3 on Jul 24, 2008 8:41:48 GMT -8
Just make sure you get the timing right. Dawn will be at 3pm Eastern Daylight. I can never keep time zones straight. You are 5 hours ahead? Then that's right.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 25, 2008 3:58:45 GMT -8
Post by witch1 on Jul 25, 2008 3:58:45 GMT -8
Let's try a post like this out.
= = = = =
Hi folks.
Pardon me for being so late with this but the incense we have to use for the séance we've had to hold recently at our Nightly gathering gives me a headache, and not the kind you can magick away either.
I just didn't want to booze the rest of the night away, because the combination of the two do some very strange things...
After some discussion we have agreed it is necessary for me to tell you that Roosh was one of our number, the Witches of Cecil Cove. We further agreed to tell you that we have seen Hal Briston baying at the moon of a Night.
Sadly, this is the only piece of information we can give you that Nanook hadn't already stumbled on, a fact that caused us to wonder if he had some sort of ability to learn who we investigated at Night.
I don't propose to divulge details of our protective actions at this time, lest it give the Town's enemies insight into our thought processes, except to reveal that we did not protect CatinaSuit on Night 1.
= = = = =
Thoughts?
I intend to post this in the Night but as close to Dawn as I can, to avoid issues arising if one of the killing factions target me; we'd then have problems with a dead player posting during the Day. Making it late means the scum can't retarget their kills onto me Tonight.
I'm not revealing W3 right now for a simple reason. If there is a second Witchdoctor in the game, and if that WD guessed right and enchanted HM, then she'll return to play at Dawn. If I blow her cover and she returns, both of us will be out in the open. On the other hand, if I don't blow her cover now and she stays dead, we're no worse off. But dammit, I'd like to see the Witchdoctor's power work for once.
If W3 doesn't get revived, I'm going to reveal that the Witches are a spent force sometime during the Day, because I think the Town need to know to correctly evaluate the threat of the various factions. The only reason not to might be to bait an attack from Vampire or Wolf; on the other hand that reduces the possibility of crosskills.
Here's hoping for some hot Vig-on-Nanook action though.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 25, 2008 9:56:25 GMT -8
Post by witch1 on Jul 25, 2008 9:56:25 GMT -8
I'm assuming no response means you're content. If you really don't want me to post this, or not reveal that we're down to one Witch, then say so pdq.
An hour or so for the former, and maybe two minutes extra for the latter.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 25, 2008 10:32:17 GMT -8
Post by witch2 on Jul 25, 2008 10:32:17 GMT -8
Thats fine.
Just make sure you tell them about the Witches being caput and all if no one enchants hockey (Which I doubt they will).
that and Let them know about Story and Dio and the fiasco there with Nanook. But that's all stuff for during the DAY.
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 25, 2008 10:36:02 GMT -8
Post by witch2 on Jul 25, 2008 10:36:02 GMT -8
At this point though, we've REALLY got to wonder about CiaS and story.
-They seem on the up and up, but I fear the "grand plan" sorta thing where Story could be the omega. The only thing against it is to wait and see and hope someone like Diggit is the omega isntead (as you've nailed down 3 wolves now with the addition of Hal. So that's like a 2/4 chance that one of them is the omega- obv. not hal since we investigated him).
But yeah... they need to know about Hal, since that whole "The first 5 voters' thing" was pretty crappy, and it should NOT be garnering the trust from players like storyteller.
That's the sort of crap I pulled just to stick to a "method" when I had the information to know that there WASN'T any real scum in a list such as that one.... Just not cool.
Tell 'em I said "Give 'em Hell' or something to bolster their spirits....
|
|
|
Night 4
Jul 25, 2008 10:47:29 GMT -8
Post by witch1 on Jul 25, 2008 10:47:29 GMT -8
Sure thing.
*Readies the post.*
|
|